Judges Critique
The QLD Boxer Club Championship Show 9th August 2026
I always
very much look forward to judging my own breed, so many thanks to the
QLD Boxer Club for the invitation, and to the members and exhibitors
who supported the show. In the current dog showing climate, I was
delighted with the entry of 44, and I do encourage the QLD Boxer
enthusiasts to maintain the momentum, as healthy levels of competition
help grow motivation in the pursuit of breeding quality Boxers. The
show had a lovely relaxed atmosphere, and it appeared from inside the
ring that exhibitors were enjoying their day out, and this was
reflected in the excellent level of sportsmanship displayed throughout
the day. The after show get-together allowed for some excellent
conversation around our breed. I very much enjoyed my day judging the
show, and I was pleased that there were many typical Boxers on show,
with some classes full of quality dogs who met breed standard
requirements. In general terms, I was pleased with the overall balance
of many dogs, with a good blend of substance to elegance in a square
outline. There was a bit of length on show in some dogs, and some
upper arms that lacked length and return. Movement was mixed, but on
the whole temperament was good. Dogs were well muscled and shown with
clean and well-presented coats. I would encourage breeders to pay some
attention to heads, as some lacked the required rise of skull, depth
and strength of muzzle, and that typical Boxer chin and lip placement.
Eyes and expression need watching too, as do mouths. Finally, many
thanks to the committee, the stewards and the sponsors for putting on
a great show. Now on to the dogs:
Baby Dog:
1: 5 month
old R/W puppy with a smooth, square outline. Well angulated both ends
with good topline and tailset, and with quality bone for size. Has an
attractive head of correct shape with clean skull and balanced muzzle.
Good mouth. He moved with soundness and style. Would just like him
slightly more substantial for his age.
2: Another
quality 5 month old R/W puppy with substance and elegance and a square
outline. Nicely angulated both ends, but just not the smooth
connection between the two that the first puppy has, particularly
across his croup to tailset. Good bone, although his feet could be
more cat like, probably due to his age. Very typical head with
excellent balance between his square muzzle and clean skull. When he
works with his handler a little more, I am sure he will do well.
Puppy Dog:
1. #4 10
month old red and white puppy dog. Very strong and substantial.
Moderate angles both ends with a square outline. Moved soundly out and
back but needed more reach and drive to provide a more energetic and
elastic gait. Head was very strong for his age and perhaps a little
over typical with, skull being quite broad. Muzzle was a very strong
but mouth was too undershot with too much chin, so did not have the
required lip placement. Dark expressive eye.
2. #3
Another red and white 10 month old puppy with a strong bone and square
appearance. Moderate angulation but needed a smoother top line and
tail set to give a more elegant outline. Front could do with a longer
upper arm and more fill in the chest. Typical head showing correct
proportions, but eyes could be slightly larger to give softer
expression. Mouth was also too undershot and lacked required width.
Intermediate
Dog:
1. #9 Very
typical B/W dog without a lot of flashy markings, but with much to
like. Very honest and ‘boxery’ in outline with a strong, square
body and balanced angulation both ends. Nothing is exaggerated about
this boy. Moved soundly but would like to see more freedom and
confidence on the move. Very typical head of excellent proportions,
with a clean skull with good rise, and a well developed muzzle with
correct chin and lip placement. In the line up for best dog, his
honest Boxer outline with substance and elegance and pleasing
expression won him the reserve best dog. RCC & Best Intermediate
in Show
2. #8 A
pleasing B/W dog of excellent overall breed type, and perhaps more
upstanding than the first place getter, with a square outline with
excellent balance between substance and elegance. Moderately angulated
in front, I would just prefer a slightly more to balance his rear
angles, and this showed a little on the move. Very typical head of
good shape, mouth and lip placement. Would like to see his eyes a
little darker and better placed to give a softer expression.
3. #11
Smaller B/W dog with pleasing square outline and balanced angulation
both ends when stood, but he moved slightly down hill when on the go
around. Typical head with correct lip placement, but would like a
little less skull to balance with his well developed muzzle, which
might provide slightly softer and more generous expression.
Australian
Bred Dog:
An interesting class - two quality Boxers
of different styles.
1. #13 Very
square and typical R/W dog with a Boxery outline. Moderate angles both
ends which meant he was balanced throughout, but I would like a little
more to give him more reach and drive with his side gait. Strong noble
neck and firm straight topline. Excellent round bone and cat feet.
Typical head with dark eyes and correct lip placement. Would like a
little less wrinkle and slightly more enthusiasm on the move.
2. #12
Stylish R/W dog with attractive general appearance. I would like
slightly more bone and substance overall. Very well built with
excellent balance between front and rear, giving him excellent
movement going around, showing correct elastic reach and drive. Head
is typical with a dark mask, although his muzzle could have more depth
and development, with a slightly more generous eye to give a softer
expression.
Open Dog:
5 entered
but only 2 present. I see from the catalogue they are litter brothers,
yet quite different!
1.
#16 The larger of the two, this dog showed very good quality, and was
strong, elegant yet powerful. He has a smooth outline, with excellent
angulation, noble neck and smooth topline. He held all this together
on the move, where he moved well, using his excellent musculation to
advantage. Quite a well balanced head in proportion to his body, he
has an excellent mouth and lip placement with a large nose and
nostrils. Would just like a little more turn up and rise of skull.
2. #15 Rich
deer red and white dog with a very square, compact, smooth and
balanced outline. Correct round bone for size. Held his topline on the
move, where he showed good reach and drive on the go around. Head was
typical, with correct pigment. Would like more rise of skull and depth
of muzzle.
Veteran
Dog:
1. #19
Nearly 9 year old B/W dog who still displayed excellent breed type. He
was very balanced throughout, with an elegant, noble neck that ran
smoothly through his well defined withers, straight, firm topline and
bang on tail set. He was well angulated in front and had strong
quarters, and these attributes showed in his harmonious movement where
he was sound up and back, and powerful and elastic on the go around.
If I could be super critical, I would like his loin to be a cm shorter
to give him a more definite square appearance, although I am sure he
would not measure long. His head was of correct shape, with clean
cheeks and lean skull, with a powerfully developed muzzle and
excellent lip placement. He still had expressive dark eyes, although
his mouth showed his age. He certainly seemed to enjoy his day out,
and his energy, confidence and true Boxer temperament won the day for
him in the Challenge line-up, where I could not go past him. CC &
Best Opposite Sex in Show. Best Veteran in Show.
Baby Bitch:
1. #20
Smart, stylish and very square, this 5 month old R/W puppy excelled in
outline, with a smooth topline from an elegant neck to her correct
highly set tail. Excellent front construction, with good bone and feet
for her size. Typical head with a clean skull and pretty expression
from dark eyes. Would like slightly more strength of muzzle, but it
remained balanced with her skull. Moved soundly and confidently for
such a youngster. Best Baby Puppy in Show.
2. #21
Another promising 5 month old R/W puppy with pleasing size, bone and
balance throughout. Very square, with good angles both ends, but just
not quite the smooth outline and level topline of the first placed
puppy. Very typical head, clean, blocky muzzle well developed in all
directions and in correct proportion to her clean skull. Eyes were
dark, but could be slightly more forward placed.
Minor Puppy
Bitch:
1. #22 6
month old B/W bitch of excellent overall breed type. Very square in
general appearance, with correct blend of substance to elegance. Good
strong round bone and well arched feet. Her topline could be a little
firmer and this showed a little on the move, where I would have liked
to see her more up in front to balance her rear, but no doubt time may
well sort this out. She was quite sound out and back. Very typical
head with clean skull in balance with her square, well developed
muzzle. Dark, well placed eye, with pretty Boxer expression. Best
Minor Puppy in Show
Puppy Bitch:
1. #27 Dark
brindle and white 6 month old puppy with a very smart, very sharp and
very balanced outline. Not the biggest puppy, and certainly not the
best behaved, but her quality shone through. Excellent balance
throughout with good angluation in front and rear, firm straight back
line with correct high set tail. Her
head was very pleasing for her age, with excellent ratio of muzzle to
skull, dark expressive eye and a good mouth. Movement was sound, but
she was unsettled, with a tendency to race, which did not always show
her to best advantage. Having said that, I liked her overall quality
and breed type. Best Puppy in Show.
2. #25
Another quality B/W bitch of 9 months of age, with typical square
outline. Presenting a slightly rangier outline, I am sure she will
fill as she get older. Slightly more angulation and strength of rear
than her front, which could have a longer, and more return, of upper
arm, but this did not show on her side gait where she showed good
reach and drive. Typical head with correct balance between muzzle and
skull, a good big nose and correct lip placement. I would have liked
her eyes slightly more forward placed to give a softer expression.
3. #23 A
promising R/W puppy bitch of 11 months of age. Very typical general
appearance, being sturdy and square with good bone. Excellent colour,
coat and presented fit and well muscled. Quite good front construction
and an excellent rear, but she could have had a more harmonious flow
from neck into topline. Typical head with black mask and well padded
muzzle. Her eyes could be slightly more generous in size to give a
more open and soft expression.
Junior Bitch:
A lovely
class of 4 quality Boxers.
1. #31 For
me, the star of the day! A lovely deer red and white bitch of great
quality, she was a beautiful combination of substance and elegance,
just right for her size. Presented in excellent condition and gleaming
red jacket, her musculation stood out plastically under her skin,
giving her strength without detracting from her elegance, style and
harmonious outline. Very well constructed, just square, with an
excellent depth and length of rib cage. Strong sharp topline that she
held on the move, where she was sound up and back and free and roomy
going round. She has a lovely head with excellent balance, clean skull
and well developed and powerful muzzle, excellent chin and lip
placement and dark expressive eyes.
Not always presenting as the seasoned show dog, I could not go
past her overall appearance, movement and typical head. Bitch CC and
BIS.
2. #28 A
quality B/W bitch who presented a very square and elegant outline,
with clean musculation and harmonious outline. Excellent rear, firm
straight topline and well arched neck, although I would just like a
little more angulation in front. Very smart on the move where she
excelled with a free and elastic side gait. Her head was typical and
of correct proportions, but she could have done with a little more
rise of skull and development of muzzle, and a slightly softer
expression.
3. #29 An
excellent R/W bitch who was very ‘boxery’ in outline. Loved her
size and substance, but could do with a touch more elegance. Excellent
round bone. Well balanced front and rear with a firm straight topline
she kept on the move. Typical head with a soft expression from dark,
well shaped eyes, good chin and lip placement. Could have done with a
little more energy and nobility on the go around.
Intermediate Bitch:
1. #32
Compact, square and sturdy R/W bitch, well constructed throughout with
balanced angles front and rear, and presenting a pleasing moderate
outline. Smooth topline. Typical head with dark eye, large nose and
good lip placement. I would like more rise of skull and development of
muzzle to give her more strength of head. Moved soundly.
2. #33
Larger framed R/W bitch of good quality and excellent angulation both
ends. Good strength of bone and body, but would like a slightly
shorter loin to give her a more compact and square shape. Very typical
head with good strength of muzzle in correct ratio to her skull, but I
would prefer less wrinkle overall. Good lip placement and chin. Moved
well.
3. #34 B/W
bitch of correct breed type with much to like. Very square, with
pleasing balance of substance and elegance. Strong back line and high
set tail and well developed rear. I would like more length and return
of her upper arm, and more fill in front to give better overall
balance. Typical head with large nose and correct chin. Eyes were dark
but I would like them slightly more generous in size to improve
expression.
Australian Bred Bitch:
1.
#37 Very smart B/W bitch who excelled in a square, sharp outline and
excellent balance between her substance and elegance. Well built
throughout, she had a particularly powerful rear, which showed in her
movement, which was alive with energy and freedom. Very typical head,
correct balance between muzzle and skull and dark eye. Perhaps
slightly more depth through would add to the quality of her
expression. Best Australian Bred in Show
2. #36
Another quality bitch of excellent breed type, with excellent bone and
substance, but still with a touch of elegance. Moderate all through, I
would like to see a some more angulation both ends, and this would
give her a little more reach and drive on the move. Very pretty head
of excellent balance, clean yet showing good strength. Excellent depth
of muzzle, with correct lip placement and typical expression.
3. #35 A
B/W bitch of excellent size and substance. Very sharp outline with
noble, well arched neck, strong topline that she held on the move and
well angulated both ends. I would like to see a slightly shorter loin
to give her a more square appearance, but her movement was powerful
and free going around, and sound up and back. Head was typical, but
could do with more rise of skull to give more depth. Mouth showing
age.
Open Bitch:
1. #39 This
is a lovely Boxer with many attributes that I look for. Nearly 6 years
old, this quality B/W bitch presented a sharp, square and balanced
outline when posed, showing both substance and elegance and great
harmony in appearance. Front assembly let her down slightly in the
challenge, and this showed a little on the move where although she
showed good reach and drive, she could have held her topline slightly
more. Her head was certainly the best on the day, showing beautiful
balance between a lean, clean skull with excellent rise, and her well
developed, blocky muzzle, with excellent chin and lip placement. Her
generous dark eye was perfectly placed giving her true Boxer
expression. A bitch of great quality and breed type. RCC and RUBIS.
Best Open in Show
2. #38 Very
well balanced B/W bitch with moderate square outline and excellent
angulation both ends, giving her a free and roomy side gait. Strong
neck with good round bone and well arched feet. Head was typical with
balanced proportions but needed slightly more turn up and a darker eye
to give softer expression.
3. #41 Very
smart R/W bitch who excels in overall construction, having excellent
front and rear angulation and a firm, straight topline. Musculation
stood out plastically under her skin, although I would like slightly
cleaner shoulders. Smooth, powerful and elastic movement. Head was
strong, with a clean skull and a well-developed muzzle, but would like
better lip placement and less flew.
Neuter Bitch:
1. #44
Quality R/W 5 year old bitch. Correct overall proportions, with a
square outline, and an elegant neck that flows well through a smooth
topline to a strong rear. Very well angulated both ends. Her overall
construction showed in her free and powerful movement. Very pretty
head with typical balance of skull and muzzle, good lip placement and
a dark expressive eye. BNOB & BNIS
2. #43
Typical 7 year old solid brindle bitch of excellent size, substance
and enough elegance to give her a very typical outline when posed.
Unfortunately she lost her topline a little on the move. Typical head
with lean, clean skull and excellent width of muzzle, which could have
been slightly shorter for perfect balance.
Mark
Johnston.